HomeNeighborhoodsFair Isle

City of Miami

Fair Isle homes for sale

8 houses for sale in Fair Isle right now, from $2.79M to $16.9M.

8houses for sale
$5.22Mmedian asking price
$1,148asking price per sq ft
57median days on market

What houses in Fair Isle actually sell for

Closed single-family sales, Dec 2024 to Sep 2026. These are prices paid, not asking prices.

$3.1Mmedian sale price23 sales
$951sold price per sq ft23 sales with size
93%of final asking pricemedian sale, 23 sales
89%of original asking pricemedian sale
57%of sellers cut the pricebefore selling
87days to sell23 sales

What houses in Fair Isle rent for

Closed single-family leases over the same period. Taxes and insurance are estimates for a buyer today, not the current owner's bills.

$15,000asking rent / month9 leases
$14,500achieved rent / month3% under asking
$5,155est. property tax / monthafter a purchase at the median
$7,795net after carry / monthrent minus tax and insurance
4.8%gross rental yielda year of rent ÷ price
2.2%net yieldafter tax and insurance
BedroomsMedian sale priceAsking rentAchieved rentDiscountEst. tax / moEst. insurance / moNet after carryGross yieldNet yieldSales / leases
4 bed$3.4M$13,750$13,5002%$5,654$1,700$6,1464.8%2.2%7 / 6

How to read this: gross yield is a year of the achieved rent divided by the median sale price for that bedroom count. Net after carry is the achieved rent minus property tax estimated at the City of Miami's 2026 adopted rate ($19.95 per $1,000 of the price a year) with no homestead exemption, since a rental does not get one (Miami-Dade reassesses at the sale, so the seller's bill does not carry over), and homeowners insurance estimated at 0.6% a year; net yield is that figure times twelve, divided by the price. Not included: vacancy, management, repairs, and your mortgage. Estimates from closed MLS data; verify before relying on them.

Map of Fair Isle: the official boundary and each house for sale8 houses for sale500 m
Boundary from the City of Miami's official neighborhood map; one dot per house for sale (the table below links each one), placed by its listing coordinates. Open in Google Maps.

About Fair Isle

Fair Isle is a City of Miami neighborhood on the Biscayne Bay side of Coconut Grove, as drawn on the City's official Miami Neighborhoods map. Fair Isle Street is the access road to Grove Isle, the 20-acre island just offshore. Nine recorded plats make up the neighborhood.

Location and access

Fair Isle Street is close to Kennedy Park, Peacock Park, the marinas and CocoWalk, and Brickell and Downtown Miami are a short drive north, per Luis Garcia Group. The nearest Metrorail stop is Coconut Grove station at 2780 SW 27th Avenue. Orange and Green Line trains share the track, so a train comes about every five to eight minutes on weekdays, and the Orange Line runs on toward Miami International Airport. Metrobus routes 22, 27 and 400 connect at the station. The station sits on the inland edge of the Grove, and the walk to the village is real, with buses covering the distance. The City of Miami Coconut Grove Trolley runs Monday to Saturday from 6:30 AM to 11:00 PM and stops at the Coconut Grove Metrorail Station and Bayside Park.

Housing stock and lots

The 23 single-family houses that closed between December 6, 2024 and September 18, 2026 had a median living area of 3,574 square feet on a median lot of 7,053 square feet. By lot size, 13 percent were under 6,000 square feet, 65 percent were 6,000 to 10,000, 17 percent were 10,000 to 20,000 and 4 percent were over 20,000. By year built, 39 percent predate 1960, 17 percent date from 1960 to 1989, 35 percent from 1990 to 2015 and 9 percent were built after 2015. Pools came with 78 percent of the houses and 35 percent were waterfront. For a buyer, the pre-1960 share makes roof age, window and door ratings, electrical and plumbing condition, and the insurer's inspection requirements the first questions. Waterfront houses add seawall condition and dock rights to the list.

Schools and parks

Coconut Grove Elementary School, a Miami-Dade County Public Schools campus at 3351 Matilda Street, serves grades PK to 5. Its 2024-2025 enrollment was 547 students, per the National Center for Education Statistics. Kennedy Park and Peacock Park are the parks named near Fair Isle Street, per Luis Garcia Group, and Bayside Park is a stop on the City's Coconut Grove trolley route.

Diligence and resale dynamics

Diligence and resale dynamics: FEMA's Flood Map Service Center gives the flood zone for each address, and the waterfront share of sales makes that lookup the first step. Building permits and code cases are searched with the City of Miami by address or folio number, and the Miami-Dade Property Appraiser shows the folio and plat. The median closed price was $3,100,000, or $951 per square foot. The median house sold for 93 percent of its final asking price after 87 days. Prices swing with the small sample. Seven sales in the first half of 2025 had a median of $2,985,000, and four in the second half of 2025 had a median of $5,141,750. Six in the first half of 2026 had a median of $2,787,500, and five from July 2026 through September 18, 2026 had a median of $3,100,000. Nine single-family leases in the same period had a median rent of $14,500 a month. A seller should expect pricing to track the size, build year and waterfront status of each house, and should expect a sale below the final asking price.

Buyers: Ask Ricky Garcia for the closed comparable sales and the diligence checklist before an offer. His help is free. Sellers: Request a free market analysis from Ricky Garcia, priced from what has actually closed. Ricky Garcia is a licensed real estate agent with Global Luxury Realty, license #3521781.

Insider notes on Fair Isle

  • Fair Isle Street is the access road to the 20-acre Grove Isle, whose three towers stand 18 stories tall.Source: Step Inside With Me
  • Grove Isle was first called Fair Isle, and the Corps of Engineers created its land in 1924 by dredging Biscayne Bay.Source: Kiddle (Grove Isle)
  • Coconut Grove Metrorail station has 199 park-and-ride spaces, and weekday trains run about every five to eight minutes.Source: Miami Metrorail
  • Metrobus routes 22, 27 and 400 connect at Coconut Grove station.Source: Wikipedia (Coconut Grove station)
  • The City of Miami Coconut Grove Trolley runs Monday to Saturday, 6:30 AM to 11:00 PM, with stops at Bayside Park and the Coconut Grove Metrorail Station.Source: City of Miami
  • Coconut Grove Elementary School had 547 students in grades PK to 5 in the 2024-2025 school year.Source: National Center for Education Statistics
  • 78 percent of the 23 single-family houses that closed from December 6, 2024 to September 18, 2026 had a pool, and 35 percent were waterfront.Source: Miami-Dade Property Appraiser
  • 65 percent of those sales were on lots of 6,000 to 10,000 square feet, and the median lot was 7,053 square feet.Source: Miami-Dade Property Appraiser
  • 39 percent of the houses that closed in that period were built before 1960, and 9 percent were built after 2015.Source: Miami-Dade Property Appraiser
  • Nine single-family leases in that period had a median rent of $14,500 a month, and the median sale reached 93 percent of final asking after 87 days.Source: Miami-Dade Property Appraiser

Houses for sale in Fair Isle

AddressPriceInsider PriceBedsBathsSq ft$/sq ftDaysListed by
1840 S Bayshore Ln
Miami 33133
$16,900,000—5612,863$1,314444Douglas Elliman
3551 Crystal Ct
Miami 33133
$7,250,000—55.54,647$1,560351One Sotheby's International Realty
1803 S Bayshore Ln
Miami 33133
$5,995,000—44.54,480$1,33860Compass Florida, LLC
3520 Rockerman Rd
Miami 33133
$5,248,000—44.54,546$1,15451Sime Realty Corporation
3550 W Glencoe St
Miami 33133
$5,195,000$4.37M to $5.35M44.54,552$1,14151Radius Realty Group LLC
1606 S Bayshore Dr
Miami 33133
$4,675,000$3.63M to $5.01M76.55,588$83718Continuum Realty LLC
3525 E Fairview St
Miami 33133
$3,950,000$3.29M to $4.02M53.54,731$83554Golden Keys Inc
1823 S Bayshore Ln
Miami 33133
$2,795,000$2.33M to $2.84M442,517$1,11086Xcellence

Insider Price is the range a house is likely to sell in, worked out from its asking price and what houses in Fair Isle actually closed at, or in a wider area where Fair Isle has had too few sales. It is not shown on Ricky Garcia's own listings, or where the seller asked that automated estimates not appear with the listing. How it works and how accurate it has been.

Ricky Garcia

Buying in Fair Isle?

Get the numbers before you write an offer

What comparable houses actually closed for, how long they took to sell, what the lot and the flood zone mean for insurance, and what to check before an offer. Ricky Garcia walks you through all of it, free, with no pressure to buy.

Ask Ricky about Fair Isle → Call (305) 33-RICKY

Recently sold in Fair Isle

23 houses closed here in the last 24 months. "Of asking" compares the sale price with the final asking price.

AddressSold forClosedOf askingBeds / bathsSq ft$/sq ftListed by
3530 Bayshore Villas Dr
Miami 33133
$8,100,000Sep 2026100%4 / 45,623$1,441One Sotheby's International Realty
1630 S Bayshore Dr
Miami 33133
$2,350,000Aug 202694%2 / 21,248$1,883Coldwell Banker Realty
1880 S Bayshore Dr
Miami 33133
$3,100,000Aug 202689%5 / 4.54,442$698Miami Portfolio Collection
1815 Fairhaven Pl
Miami 33133
$6,550,000Jul 202694%4 / 43,665$1,787BHHS EWM Realty
1616 S Bayshore Dr
Miami 33133
$2,850,000Jul 202690%4 / 43,279$869Compass Florida, LLC
3211 Morris Ln
Coconut Grove 33133
$2,800,000Jun 202693%5 / 43,439$814Blackbook Properties
3535 W Glencoe St
Miami 33133
$1,650,000May 202697%3 / 2.51,735$951Compass Florida, LLC
1755 Fairhaven Pl
Miami 33133
$8,387,500May 202695%5 / 5.55,378$1,560The Corcoran Group
3551 E Glencoe St
Miami 33133
$2,200,000Apr 202694%4 / 32,334$943BHHS EWM Realty
3566 Rockerman Rd
Miami 33133
$4,100,000Feb 202693%6 / 4.53,370$1,217BHHS EWM Realty
1870 S Bayshore Dr
Miami 33133
$2,775,000Jan 202687%5 / 4.54,611$602Coldwell Banker Realty
3545 E Glencoe St
Miami 33133
$2,700,000Nov 202592%4 / 3.53,114$867Compass Florida, LLC
1716 S Bayshore Dr
Miami 33133
$7,000,000Aug 202570%0 / 010,384$674Compass Florida, LLC.
3504 Bayshore Villas Dr
Miami 33133
$3,283,500Jul 202588%5 / 4.55,430$605Douglas Elliman
1740 S Bayshore Ln
Miami 33133
$8,000,000Jul 202578%9 / 11.57,335$1,091Coldwell Banker Realty
3520 Fair Isle St
Coconut Grove 33133
$2,750,000Jun 202592%3 / 3.53,514$783Compass Florida, LLC
3540 E Glencoe St
Miami 33133
$1,738,000May 2025104%3 / 21,110$1,566Coldwell Banker Realty
3515 E Fairview St
Miami 33133
$4,450,000May 202589%6 / 74,753$936One Sotheby's International Realty
3240 Morris Ln
Miami 33133
$2,985,000Apr 202592%3 / 33,001$995Luxe Properties
3555 Crystal View Ct
Miami 33133
$3,400,000Mar 202595%4 / 3.54,021$846Avanti Way Realty LLC
3505 Crystal View Ct
Miami 33133
$1,622,000Mar 202594%3 / 21,484$1,093Douglas Elliman
3560 Crystal View Ct
Miami 33133
$5,550,000Mar 202597%4 / 4.53,660$1,516One Sotheby's International Realty
1820 S Bayshore Dr
Miami 33133
$7,000,000Dec 202497%5 / 4.53,574$1,959BHHS EWM Realty

Selling in Fair Isle?

What Fair Isle houses actually sell for

These numbers come from closed MLS sales in Fair Isle, not asking prices. The pattern is the same in every neighborhood: houses priced to the market go under contract in weeks; overpriced houses sit, get cut, and close lower. Ricky Garcia prepares a free market analysis for your house: what comparable houses actually closed for, what is competing with you right now, and a list price that gets showings in the first two weeks. No obligation.

23sales closed, last 24 months
89%of the original asking price (median sale)
57%of sellers cut their price before selling
87 daysto sell (median)
$951per sq ft, recent sales

Get my free market analysis → Call (305) 33-RICKY

Fair Isle house prices: questions and answers

How much do houses cost in Fair Isle?

8 houses for sale in Fair Isle right now, from $2.79M to $16.9M. The median asking price is $5,221,500, or $1,148 per square foot of living area. Houses that actually sold between Dec 2024 and Sep 2026 closed at a median of $3,100,000 (23 sales).

How far below the asking price do houses sell in Fair Isle?

Across 23 closed sales between Dec 2024 and Sep 2026, the median house in Fair Isle sold for 93.4% of its final asking price and 88.8% of its original asking price. 57% of sellers cut the price before selling.

How long does it take to sell a house in Fair Isle?

The median house that sold in Fair Isle between Dec 2024 and Sep 2026 was on the market for 87 days (23 sales). The houses for sale now have been listed for a median of 57 days.

What are property taxes on a house in Fair Isle?

The 2026 adopted tax rate for Miami is 19.9544 mills, or $19.95 of tax for every $1,000 of taxable value. On a house bought at $3,100,000, the median sale price here, that is about $61,859 a year with no homestead exemption and about $59,693 with one, for an owner who was a Florida resident by December 31, 2026. The seller's bill does not carry over: the assessed value resets as of the January 1 after the sale.

What does a house rent for in Fair Isle?

The median single-family lease that closed in Fair Isle over the same period was signed at $14,500 a month (9 leases). Against the median sale price, that is a gross rental yield of 4.8% a year before taxes, insurance and repairs.

What is the Insider Price on a Fair Isle listing?

It is the price range a house is likely to sell in, worked out from its asking price and the share of asking that houses in Fair Isle and in its price range actually closed at. Where too few houses have sold there, the sales of a wider area are used. In a test on a year of Miami-Dade sales, about nine in ten of the houses that sold did so inside the range. It is an estimate from closed MLS data, not an appraisal, and it is not shown where the seller asked that automated estimates not appear with the listing.

Before you buy or sell in Fair Isle

Miami-Dade property taxes after you buy: why the seller's bill will not be yoursA Miami-Dade house is reassessed at market value on January 1 after a sale. 2026 millage by city, homestead amounts and a $900,000 worked example.Flood zones in Miami-Dade: what a house buyer needs to knowMiami-Dade flood zones explained: AE, AH, VE and X, FEMA's February 19, 2027 map date, lender rules, Citizens' flood requirement and seller disclosure.Homeowners and windstorm insurance for a Miami-Dade houseHow insurers price a Miami-Dade house: roof age rules, 4-point and wind mitigation inspections, hurricane deductibles, Citizens eligibility and grants.Which inspections to order before buying a Miami-Dade houseInspections that matter for a Miami-Dade house, what each finds, national cost ranges, and how the standard AS IS contract's inspection period works.How to check a Miami-Dade house for open permits, unpermitted work and code liensHow to search permits, code cases and liens on a Miami-Dade house, what an open permit means for a buyer, and how to spot unpermitted additions.How to price a Miami-Dade house so it sellsMiami-Dade houses that sold November 2024 to November 2026 got a median 97.2% of final asking price. How to build a price from comparable sales.Property tax calculatorThe tax bill after a purchase, with and without a homestead exemption.Closing cost calculatorThe cash a buyer needs at closing, beyond the down payment.Negotiating roomHow far under asking houses actually sold, by neighborhood and price range.

All guides →   All Insider Tools →

Nearby neighborhoods

What's my Fair Isle home worth?

23 houses sold in Fair Isle in the last 24 months, at a median of $3.1M. Is yours above or below that? Give Ricky the address and he'll email you a price range built from those sales, with the sales listed. You don't have to list with him.

Escríbale en español si prefiere.

Add a note

Your message goes to Ricky's own inbox and is used only to answer you, never sold. Asking costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Or call (305) 337-4259.

How we decide what's in Fair Isle: each house is placed by its county property record and the City of Miami's official neighborhood map, not by what the listing calls itself.