HomeInsider ToolsHow the Insider Price works

Insider Tools

How the Insider Price works

The Insider Price is the price range a house for sale is likely to close in. It is worked out from the asking price and from what houses in the same neighborhood and price range actually sold for.

In short
  • The Insider Price is the price range a house for sale is likely to close in: a middle figure with a range around it.
  • It is the asking price multiplied by the share of asking that houses in the same neighborhood and price range actually sold for.
  • Tested on 10,542 Miami-Dade sales that closed from December 2025 through November 2026. The last estimate the site would have shown before each sale was within 10% of the sale price for 92% of them. The first estimate, made from the price the house was first listed at, was within 10% for 80%.
  • It is an estimate from closed MLS data, not an appraisal and not an offer. It is not shown on Ricky Garcia's own listings or where the seller opted out.

What the Insider Price is

A listing shows an asking price. Most houses sell for less than they ask, some sell for more, and how much less depends on the neighborhood and the price range. The Insider Price turns that history into an estimate of the sale price for each house that is for sale now.

It is always shown as a range, because one number would claim more precision than the method has. On a house page you see the middle figure and the range; in the neighborhood tables and on the home page you see the range.

How it is worked out

  1. Start from the asking price. The current one, after any price cuts.
  2. Find the comparable history. The closed sales of single-family houses over the last 12 months in the same neighborhood and the same price range (under $500,000; $500,000 to $1 million; $1 million to $2 million; $2 million to $5 million; over $5 million). At least 8 sales are needed. With fewer, the whole neighborhood is used; then the whole county in that price range.
  3. Take the median ratio. For each of those sales, divide the sale price by the final asking price. The median of those ratios, the one in the middle when they are sorted, is the share of asking that houses like this one actually closed at.
  4. Multiply. Asking price times that ratio is the middle of the Insider Price.
  5. Set the range by how long the house has been listed. 16% either side for a listing under 30 days old with no price cut; 10% from 30 to 90 days; 8% after a price cut or 90 days on the market.

Example. A house asks $1,000,000. Houses in its neighborhood and price range sold, at the median, for 97% of their final asking price. The middle of its Insider Price is $970,000. Listed 45 days with no price cut, it shows a range of $873,000 to $1,067,000. The same house in its first month would show $814,800 to $1,125,200, and once it had been listed 90 days, $892,400 to $1,047,600. A price cut lowers the middle figure too, because the estimate starts from the new asking price.

How accurate it has been

The method was tested on every Miami-Dade single-family sale in the MLS that closed from December 2025 through November 2026 and could be scored: 10,542 sales. The estimate for a house changes while it is for sale, because it starts from the asking price and the asking price can be cut. The site was not yet running when these houses sold, so the test works out the estimates it would have shown. Each sale was scored twice: once for the last estimate before it sold, and once for the first.

The last estimate before the sale

This is the house's final asking price times the ratio. The ratio came only from sales that closed before the first day of the month the house closed in, so the test never uses a sale the site could not have known about. The estimate was then compared with the price the house actually sold for.

2.3%median errorhalf the estimates were closer than this
77%within 5%of the sale price
92%within 10%of the sale price
96%within 15%of the sale price

For comparison, treating the final asking price itself as the prediction gave a median error of 3.2%, with 86% of sales within 10%. The Insider Price is closer because it removes the usual gap between asking and selling for that neighborhood and price range.

The first estimate, before any price cut

This is the price the house was first listed at times the ratio, using only the sales that had closed before the month it was listed. The MLS sale record carries no listing date, so that month is worked out from the closing date and the days on the market, allowing 30 days between contract and closing. This is the harder test: the estimate cannot know which sellers will go on to cut their price.

3.7%median errorhalf the estimates were closer than this
60%within 5%of the sale price
80%within 10%of the sale price
89%within 15%of the sale price

The first estimate was above the sale price for 64% of the houses and below it for the rest. For comparison, the original asking price itself had a median error of 5.5%, with 71% of sales within 10%.

Did the house sell inside the range?

The range is wider on a new listing and narrower on an older one. This table counts how often the sale price fell inside the range the page would have shown.

What was countedRange shownSalesSold inside it
Every sale, against the range for its first month16% either side10,53290%
Houses that sold in under 30 days with no price cut16% either side3,90997%
Houses that sold after 30 to 90 days with no price cut10% either side1,80792%
Houses that sold after a price cut or 90 days8% either side4,82689%

The first row is the one that matters on a new listing: its range has to allow for the price cuts still ahead of it. In the other three rows the range is the one for the stage the listing was in when it sold. About one house in ten sold outside its range. Only houses that sold are counted: a house taken off the market without selling has no sale price to compare with.

The two tables below use the last estimate before the sale.

Accuracy by price range

Asking priceSales testedMedian errorWithin 5%Within 10%
Under $500,0001,7002.5%71%85%
$500,000 to $1 million5,8402.0%84%95%
$1 million to $2 million1,6983.6%66%91%
$2 million to $5 million8793.4%67%93%
Over $5 million4253.6%67%92%

Accuracy by neighborhood

Every neighborhood with at least 25 sales in the test, the largest first. Click a column to sort. A neighborhood with fewer sales is not listed here; its houses still get an Insider Price from the wider history described above.

NeighborhoodSales testedMedian errorWithin 5%Within 10%
Miami Gardens6201.8%79%90%
Hialeah4711.7%82%95%
Homestead3641.5%89%96%
Coral Gables3613.6%61%91%
Cutler Bay3491.6%87%96%
Kendall2922.9%74%95%
Palmetto Bay2873.1%77%94%
Doral2292.5%81%96%
Westchester2262.5%77%92%
Miami Beach2253.7%64%88%
Princeton2211.4%87%96%
North Miami2142.9%70%87%
The Hammocks2052.1%88%97%
Pinecrest2023.0%73%96%
Richmond West1951.5%89%97%
Tamiami1852.4%82%96%
South Miami Heights1751.6%86%96%
West Little River1722.0%75%86%
Miami Shores1523.5%65%88%
Leisure City1431.0%86%93%
North Miami Beach1413.0%74%87%
Coral Terrace1363.0%74%90%
Kendale Lakes1342.3%81%96%
Biscayne Gardens1292.5%68%87%
Flagami1272.6%78%91%
Miami Lakes1262.5%81%92%
Country Walk1221.7%84%99%
Redland1103.1%64%94%
Sunset1072.7%81%98%
Goulds1001.6%81%93%
Palmetto Estates921.9%82%89%
The Crossings902.1%86%99%
South Miami893.3%69%89%
Brownsville872.0%79%86%
Gladeview862.5%69%84%
Richmond Heights862.5%78%92%
Miami Springs823.6%80%96%
Kendall West812.0%80%96%
Glenvar Heights783.3%72%90%
Olympia Heights732.6%78%90%
Ojus724.2%57%86%
South Grove654.3%55%92%
Country Club651.4%80%89%
Ives Estates652.5%86%92%
Opa-locka621.3%82%89%
Three Lakes612.7%87%97%
West Perrine601.7%72%85%
Westwood Lakes592.2%78%90%
Westview563.0%64%82%
Florida City552.0%76%89%
Shenandoah North514.1%61%88%
The Roads503.9%64%92%
Surfside483.6%69%96%
Hadley Park462.8%74%83%
Biscayne Park464.3%59%87%
Shorecrest424.8%55%88%
Silver Bluff423.6%67%88%
Shenandoah South413.0%76%88%
Pinewood412.5%78%88%
Buena Vista West403.6%65%88%
Key Biscayne403.3%73%98%
Fountainebleau401.6%88%93%
Auburndale392.4%90%100%
Hialeah Gardens351.8%89%100%
High Pines and Ponce-Davis333.4%76%97%
Palm Springs North322.9%66%88%
Edison313.4%68%90%
Flora Park292.4%79%90%
North Grove282.9%71%93%
El Portal271.7%70%96%
Aventura262.7%88%92%

Test run on November 15, 2026 on 21,566 closed sales dated November 13, 2024 to November 13, 2026. Sales whose recorded price was less than a third or more than three times the asking price were left out as keying errors. The test is repeated as new months of sales arrive.

What it cannot tell you

  • Whether the asking price is reasonable. The estimate starts from the asking price. A house priced far above its market will show an Insider Price that is too high until the seller cuts. As a check, each house is also compared with recent sales of similar houses in and around its neighborhood, and the house page says so when the asking price is at least 30% above what those sales point to. That comparison is rough: in the test, 89% of the houses it marked still sold inside their range (93% of the others did). What it did show was more room to negotiate: 25% of the marked houses sold for more than 10% under the price they were asking when they sold, against 10% of the others.
  • The condition of the house. The formula does not see a new roof, an old kitchen, work done without a permit or a view. Two houses with the same asking price on the same street get the same Insider Price.
  • Thin markets. It is least precise under $500,000 and above $1 million (the table above), and in neighborhoods with few sales, where it borrows the county's history.
  • The future. It is built on the last 12 months of sales. If prices turn quickly, it follows with a delay.

Before an offer, the closed comparable sales for the specific house matter more than any formula. Ask Ricky Garcia for them; he is a licensed real estate agent with Global Luxury Realty and sends them at no cost.

Where you will not see it

  • Where the seller opted out. A listing in the MLS carries a setting that says whether automated estimates may be shown with it. Where the seller said no, this site shows no Insider Price on the house. Right now that is 2,470 of the 4,938 houses for sale (50%).
  • Ricky Garcia's own listings. He represents those sellers, so this site shows no estimate, price comparison or negotiating figure on them.
  • Houses that are not for sale. The method needs an asking price. If you own a house and want to know what it would sell for, ask for a price range built from the sales near you.

How this compares with a Zestimate

Zillow publishes the accuracy of its own estimate. On its Zestimate page, in figures it last refreshed on November 8, 2026, it reports a nationwide median error of 1.80% for homes that are for sale and 7.21% for homes that are not. The Insider Price's 2.3% (the last estimate before the sale) and 3.7% (the first estimate) are for single-family houses for sale in Miami-Dade County only. The two figures are measured on different homes, so they are not a like-for-like comparison. What this page adds is the breakdown: the result for each price range and each neighborhood, and how often a house sold outside its range.

Questions and answers

Is the Insider Price an appraisal?

No. It is an estimate from closed MLS sales, made by a formula that never sees the inside of the house. An appraisal is an opinion of value by a state-licensed appraiser who inspects the property, and a lender orders one before it approves a loan.

Why do some houses show no Insider Price?

Three reasons. The seller asked, through a setting in the MLS listing, that automated estimates not appear with it. Or the house is one of Ricky Garcia's own listings: he represents that seller, so this site shows no estimate on it. Or the listing has no asking price to start from.

Why is the range wider on a new listing?

A house listed for less than 30 days that has not cut its price has not been tested by buyers yet, and its price may still be cut. In the test, a range of 16% either side of the first estimate was needed for nine sales in ten to close inside it. After a price cut or 90 days on the market the range narrows to 8%.

Can the Insider Price be higher than the asking price?

The top of the range can be. Some houses do sell above their asking price, usually new listings in price ranges with several buyers for each house. The middle figure is above the asking price only where houses like it have recently sold, at the median, for more than they asked.

How often is the Insider Price updated?

Every night. Closed sales are pulled from the MLS once a day, and each house for sale is then estimated again from the last 12 months of sales. A price cut during the day shows in the estimate the next morning.

Does the Insider Price tell me what to offer?

No. It tells you where houses like this one have usually ended up relative to their asking prices. What to offer on one house depends on its condition, its permits, its flood zone and the sales on its own street. Ricky Garcia sends the closed comparable sales for any house on this site at no cost.

Ricky Garcia

What's my home worth?

Give Ricky the address and he'll email you a price range built from recent sales nearby, with the sales listed. You don't have to list with him.

Escríbale en español si prefiere.

Add a note

Your message goes to Ricky's own inbox and is used only to answer you, never sold. Asking costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Or call (305) 337-4259.

An estimate from closed MLS data, not an appraisal and not an offer.