HomeNeighborhoodsCutler Bay10265 Montego Bay Dr, Cutler Bay 33189

Cutler Bay

10265 Montego Bay Dr, Cutler Bay 33189

Single-family home in Cutler Bay.

10265 Montego Bay Dr, Cutler Bay 33189
$659,000asking price
$424per sq ft
4 / 3beds / baths
3days on market
NeighborhoodCutler Bay
Living area1,556 sq ft
Lot9,468 sq ft
Year built1957
Garage0
PoolNo
WaterfrontNo
Flood zoneAE High-risk flood zone (Special Flood Hazard Area). Federal flood insurance required for federally-backed mortgages.
Annual taxes$7,226
MLS numberA12125559

No Insider Price is shown for this house: the seller asked that automated estimates not appear with the listing. Ricky Garcia can send you the closed comparable sales instead; ask below.

Estimated monthly cost

Mortgage (principal and interest)$3,419
Property tax after purchase$979
Homeowners insurance (estimate)$330
Total per month$4,728

How these figures are worked out. The mortgage line is a 30-year fixed-rate loan at 6.75% a year with 20% down ($131,800 paid at closing): the site's 2026 working assumption, not a lender's quote; change the loan terms above to see your own. Property tax uses the 2026 adopted tax rate of Cutler Bay, called millage: $17.82 for every $1,000 of taxable value (the value the tax is charged on, after any exemptions), applied to the full price. The tax line carries no homestead exemption: the first bill after a purchase usually has none, and a second home or a rental never gets one. 2027 tax rates are not set yet, so the 2026 rates are used. Homeowners insurance is estimated at 0.6% of the price a year, the site's 2026 working figure; flood and windstorm cover vary by house, and an insurance agent quotes the real figure. At these default terms the total is about $3.04 per square foot of living area a month.

With a homestead exemption (if this becomes your primary residence), the tax would be about $825 a month, from the first January 1 after you move in. A homestead exemption lowers the taxable value of a house its owner lives in as a main home; it is applied for by March 1. The figure uses the 2027 exemption amounts from Amendment 3 (approved by Florida voters on November 3, 2026) for an owner who was a Florida resident by December 31, 2026; the law to carry it out had not passed as of November 14, 2026. Try other cases in the property tax calculator, or read how property tax changes after you buy.

The current owner's tax bill is about $602 a month. It does not carry over: Miami-Dade sets a new assessed value at the sale price as of the January 1 after the sale, which is why the estimate above is higher.

This house is in flood zone AE; a lender will require flood insurance on top of the homeowners estimate above.

About this home

The listing agent's description, as it appears in the MLS:

No detail has been overlooked in this impressive luxury 3 Bed 3 full bath executive home in Cutler Bay. Over 2100 sq ft of bright living spaces, with great room, dining area all of which have been lovingly renovated to perfection. A lovely sun filled Chef’s kitchen all quality built with amazing details, spacious bedrooms that include a splendid master suite with faultless luxury bath. All new matching tile floors throughout. Incredible oversized covered patio and fenced and gated 9468 corner lot. Upgrades include newer tin roof, impact glass, all PVC plumbing, upgraded closets, and boat pad all on a great low traffic street. Absolutely turnkey making this a BEST Value and Lifestyle opportunity! This amazing home is not to be missed, make your appointment to preview the home right away!

Recently sold in Cutler Bay

Closed sale prices from the MLS over the last 24 months, newest first, limited to houses within 30% of this one's living area; "of asking" is the sale price as a share of the final asking price. See every recent sale in Cutler Bay.

AddressSold forClosedOf askingBeds / bathsSq ft$/sq ftListed by
20530 Eagle Nest Rd$500,000Nov 202691%3 / 21,327$377Conde Realty
10330 Puerto Rico Dr$520,000Nov 202699%3 / 21,852$281Majestic Properties LLC
8514 SW 209th Ln$599,999Nov 2026100%4 / 21,665$360Avenew Realty Corp
10020 SW 223rd Ln$555,000Nov 202698%4 / 2.51,967$282Coldwell Banker Realty
Address withheld (MLS A12056179)$625,000Nov 202694%3 / 21,957$319London Foster Realty
8920 SW 197th St$624,000Nov 202698%3 / 21,682$371Compass Florida, LLC
9021 SW 197th St$637,000Nov 202698%3 / 21,404$454London Foster Realty
8935 SW 186th Ter$705,000Nov 202693%3 / 21,300$542Chez Realty, LLC.

Check the public record

Official records for this house, free to search by its address. Each office keeps a different part of the record.

What to look for: open permits and code violations and flood zones for Miami-Dade houses.

Ricky Garcia

Ask Ricky about this home

Is it still available, is the price right, and what should you check before an offer? Ricky can show you any house listed here, whoever the listing agent is.

Escríbale en español si prefiere.

Your message goes to Ricky's own inbox and is used only to answer you, never sold. Asking costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Or call (305) 337-4259.

Listing courtesy of Village Realty of S. Florida
Information provided by Miami Association of Realtors / SEFMLS. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed. • MLS # A12125559 • Updated Nov 21, 2026