Home›Neighborhoods›Cutler Bay›9365 Jamaica Dr, Cutler Bay 33189
Cutler Bay
9365 Jamaica Dr, Cutler Bay 33189
Single-family home in Cutler Bay.

Insider Price
$620K likely $570K to $669K
What this house would probably sell for, from the asking price and the share of asking that houses in this neighborhood actually closed at (291 sales); the margin narrows after a price cut or ninety days on the market.
Comparable sales checked: 320. The 5 most similar are listed here
- 9500 Cutler Ridge Dr: $560,000 on Sep 2026, 1,944 sq ft
- 9851 Jamaica Dr: $660,000 on Jul 2026, 1,742 sq ft
- 9395 Nassau Dr: $600,000 on Sep 2026, 1,799 sq ft
- 9110 SW 200 St: $580,000 on Sep 2026, 1,861 sq ft
- 9401 Jamaica Dr: $570,000 on May 2026, 1,501 sq ft
An estimate from closed MLS data, not an appraisal and not an offer. Ask Ricky for the full comparable-sales analysis before you make an offer.
Estimated monthly cost
| Mortgage (principal and interest) | $3,264 |
| Property tax after purchase | $934 |
| Homeowners insurance (estimate) | $315 |
| Total per month | $4,512 |
How these figures are worked out. The mortgage line is a 30-year fixed-rate loan at 6.75% a year with 20% down ($125,800 paid at closing): the site's 2026 working assumption, not a lender's quote; change the loan terms above to see your own. Property tax uses the 2026 adopted tax rate of Cutler Bay, called millage: $17.82 for every $1,000 of taxable value (the value the tax is charged on, after any exemptions), applied to the full price. The tax line carries no homestead exemption: the first bill after a purchase usually has none, and a second home or a rental never gets one. 2027 tax rates are not set yet, so the 2026 rates are used. Homeowners insurance is estimated at 0.6% of the price a year, the site's 2026 working figure; flood and windstorm cover vary by house, and an insurance agent quotes the real figure. At these default terms the total is about $2.34 per square foot of living area a month.
With a homestead exemption (if this becomes your primary residence), the tax would be about $780 a month, from the first January 1 after you move in. A homestead exemption lowers the taxable value of a house its owner lives in as a main home; it is applied for by March 1. The figure uses the 2027 exemption amounts from Amendment 3 (approved by Florida voters on November 3, 2026) for an owner who was a Florida resident by December 31, 2026; the law to carry it out had not passed as of November 14, 2026. Try other cases in the property tax calculator, or read how property tax changes after you buy.
The current owner's tax bill is about $246 a month. It does not carry over: Miami-Dade sets a new assessed value at the sale price as of the January 1 after the sale, which is why the estimate above is higher.
About this home
The listing agent's description, as it appears in the MLS:
NEW PRICE OF $629,000! NO FLOOD ZONE! INCREDIBLE VALUE IN DESIRABLE CUTLER BAY! Beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom 1,928 living sq. ft. home featuring a newer roof, newer A/C, updated kitchen with quartz countertops, renovated bathrooms, and new flooring throughout. A spacious laundry room adds tons of additional storage. A cozy, real fireplace adds warmth and charm, creating the perfect space to relax and unwind. Enjoy South Florida living at its finest with an expansive covered outdoor entertaining area, perfect for weekend BBQ's, family gatherings, or simply relaxing in the shade. This property also offers a private fenced-in backyard with a mature, fruit-bearing avocado tree, a large concrete shed for storage, and a 70-foot concrete slab with an RV hookup. Lovingly cared for by the same owners for 25 years, this home is situated in a vibrant community known for its active social calendar, including golf cart parades, chili cook-offs, and wing-fests. Conveniently located just minutes from the Turnpike, Black Point Marina, and the exciting redevelopment of Southland Mall into Southplace City Center. This is a must-see—bring your offers!
Recently sold in Cutler Bay
Closed sale prices from the MLS over the last 24 months, newest first, limited to houses within 30% of this one's living area; "of asking" is the sale price as a share of the final asking price. See every recent sale in Cutler Bay.
| Address | Sold for | Closed | Of asking | Beds / baths | Sq ft | $/sq ft | Listed by |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9780 Bel Aire Dr | $780,000 | Nov 2026 | 95% | 5 / 3 | 2,184 | $357 | EXP Realty, LLC |
| 10330 Puerto Rico Dr | $520,000 | Nov 2026 | 99% | 3 / 2 | 1,852 | $281 | Majestic Properties LLC |
| 9412 SW 184th Ter | $650,000 | Nov 2026 | 97% | 4 / 2 | 2,266 | $287 | Brown Harris Stevens |
| 8514 SW 209th Ln | $599,999 | Nov 2026 | 100% | 4 / 2 | 1,665 | $360 | Avenew Realty Corp |
| 10020 SW 223rd Ln | $555,000 | Nov 2026 | 98% | 4 / 2.5 | 1,967 | $282 | Coldwell Banker Realty |
| 9359 Dominican Dr | $700,000 | Nov 2026 | 100% | 3 / 2 | 2,218 | $316 | Enkasa, Inc. |
| Address withheld (MLS A12056179) | $625,000 | Nov 2026 | 94% | 3 / 2 | 1,957 | $319 | London Foster Realty |
| 8920 SW 197th St | $624,000 | Nov 2026 | 98% | 3 / 2 | 1,682 | $371 | Compass Florida, LLC |
Check the public record
Official records for this house, free to search by its address. Each office keeps a different part of the record.
- Miami-Dade Property Appraiser, property search. Search by the address or the folio number (the 13-digit number the Property Appraiser gives each property). The record shows the building sketch and the recorded living area when a sketch is on file, which can be compared with the square footage in the listing.
- Miami-Dade Property Appraiser, city building department contacts. Each city keeps its own permit records. This Property Appraiser page lists every city's building department contact.
- Miami-Dade County, Flood Zone Maps. Enter the address to see the current flood zone, then switch to the preliminary view to see the new map, for which FEMA has set a date of February 19, 2027.
What to look for: open permits and code violations and flood zones for Miami-Dade houses.

Ask Ricky about this home
Is it still available, is the price right, and what should you check before an offer? Ricky can show you any house listed here, whoever the listing agent is.
Escríbale en español si prefiere.
Information provided by Miami Association of Realtors / SEFMLS. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed. • MLS # A11984056 • Updated Nov 10, 2026