HomeNeighborhoodsCutler BayPage 2

Miami-Dade County

Cutler Bay homes for sale

156 houses for sale in Cutler Bay right now, from $370K to $3.3M.

156houses for sale
$700Kmedian asking price
$369asking price per sq ft
66median days on market

What houses in Cutler Bay actually sell for

Closed single-family sales, Nov 2024 to Nov 2026. These are prices paid, not asking prices.

$629Kmedian sale price723 sales
$355sold price per sq ft710 sales with size
98%of final asking pricemedian sale, 722 sales
96%of original asking pricemedian sale
47%of sellers cut the pricebefore selling
44days to sell723 sales

What houses in Cutler Bay rent for

Closed single-family leases over the same period. Taxes and insurance are estimates for a buyer today, not the current owner's bills.

$3,500asking rent / month348 leases
$3,500achieved rent / month0% under asking
$934est. property tax / monthafter a purchase at the median
$2,251net after carry / monthrent minus tax and insurance
6.8%gross rental yielda year of rent ÷ price
4.4%net yieldafter tax and insurance
BedroomsMedian sale priceAsking rentAchieved rentDiscountEst. tax / moEst. insurance / moNet after carryGross yieldNet yieldSales / leases
2 bed$440K$2,550$2,600—$653$220$1,7277.1%4.7%19 / 6
3 bed$585K$3,200$3,2000%$869$293$2,0396.6%4.2%340 / 160
4 bed$650K$3,775$3,7002%$965$325$2,4106.8%4.4%260 / 114
5 bed$833K$5,400$5,2004%$1,236$416$3,5477.5%5.1%96 / 61

How to read this: gross yield is a year of the achieved rent divided by the median sale price for that bedroom count. Net after carry is the achieved rent minus property tax estimated at Cutler Bay's 2026 adopted rate ($17.82 per $1,000 of the price a year) with no homestead exemption, since a rental does not get one (Miami-Dade reassesses at the sale, so the seller's bill does not carry over), and homeowners insurance estimated at 0.6% a year; net yield is that figure times twelve, divided by the price. Not included: vacancy, management, repairs, and your mortgage. Estimates from closed MLS data; verify before relying on them.

Houses for sale in Cutler Bay (61–120 of 156)

AddressPriceInsider PriceBedsBathsSq ft$/sq ftDaysListed by
8950 SW 197th St
Cutler Bay 33157
$750,000—322,490$301120Global Group Realty, LLC
20120 SW 84th Pl
Cutler Bay 33189
$750,000—421,718$43764Coldwell Banker Realty
9390 SW 190th St
Cutler Bay 33157
$750,000—421,474$50911BHHS EWM Realty
8284 SW 205th Ter
Cutler Bay 33189
$749,000—532,489$30165Florida Capital Realty
7645 SW 193rd Ln
Cutler Bay 33157
$749,000$679K to $797K432,723$27515Luxe Properties
8765 SW 208th St
Cutler Bay 33189
$740,000—432,934$252110Capital Trust Real Estate Corp
19762 Bel Aire Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$740,000$612K to $846K532,034$3648Modern International Real Estate INC
9720 Caribbean Blvd
Cutler Bay 33189
$739,990$656K to $802K532,379$31153Charles Rutenberg Realty FTL
19511 Sterling Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$739,000—321,557$47596Miami Portfolio Collection
9351 Jamaica Dr
Cutler Bay 33189
$736,000—321,685$43738ACE Florida Realty, LLC
9770 Cutler Ridge Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$734,000—421,443$509109BHHS EWM Realty
8830 Caribbean Blvd
Cutler Bay 33157
$730,000$662K to $777K642,818$25956Real Estate Connection of South Florida
18681 Belview Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$714,900$648K to $760K421,929$371122BHHS EWM Realty
yanez.s@ewm.com
20605 SW 82nd Ct
Cutler Bay 33189
$714,500$591K to $816K322,033$35118The Keyes Company
20001 Ranch Rd
Cutler Bay 33189
$710,000$643K to $755K321,778$39995RE/MAX Advance Realty II
20150 SW 89th Ct
Cutler Bay 33189
$700,000—642,198$318313The Salazar Group Real Estate, LLC.
19911 SW 84th Ave
Cutler Bay 33189
$700,000$634K to $745K421,744$401226Rockstar International Realty
9837 SW 194th St
Cutler Bay 33157
$700,000—321,666$420219Lifestyle International Realty
19390 Whispering Pines Rd
Cutler Bay 33157
$700,000$634K to $745K321,688$415114RE/MAX Advance Realty II
(305) 989-3200
9420 SW 212th Terrace
Cutler Bay 33189
$699,999—531,952$359303Real Estate Empire Group, Inc.
18645 SW 90th Ave
Cutler Bay 33157
$699,000$633K to $744K321,953$358177BHHS EWM Realty
19120 Bel Aire Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$699,000$633K to $744K321,200$583131JFA Realty Co
8005 SW 198th Ter
Cutler Bay 33189
$699,000—321,825$38367South Florida Global R.E. LLC
9270 Caribbean Blvd
Cutler Bay 33157
$699,000$578K to $799K321,875$37329Cutler Realty, Inc.
10045 SW 199th St
Cutler Bay 33157
$699,000$578K to $799K421,908$3669Charles Rutenberg Realty FTL
20221 SW 85th Ct
Cutler Bay 33189
$695,300—421,782$39046United Realty Group Inc
9730 SW 219th St
Cutler Bay 33190
$695,000$630K to $739K422,107$330403BHHS EWM Realty
yanez.s@ewm.com
20301 SW 105th Ave
Cutler Bay 33189
$689,900—321,943$355109Luxe Properties
9741 Bahama Dr
Cutler Bay 33189
$680,000—422,067$32984Realty One Group Evolution
8730 SW 190th St
Cutler Bay 33157
$679,000—321,218$55754South Dade Realty Inc
8111 SW 205th St
Cutler Bay 33189
$675,000—331,840$36761Dezer Platinum Realty LLC
9383 SW 227th Ln
Cutler Bay 33190
$675,000—42.52,429$27841Xcellence
18650 SW 98th Ave
Cutler Bay 33157
$675,000$558K to $771K311,307$5162Luxe Properties
22023 SW 95th Pl
Cutler Bay 33190
$670,000$594K to $726K322,062$32574Miami Home Brokers Realty
20233 SW 85th Court
Cutler Bay 33189
$669,900$607K to $713K321,701$394104Preferred Property Finder Inc.
10521 Caribbean Blvd
Cutler Bay 33189
$668,500—431,744$38370Vibe PV LLC
20288 SW 85th Ave
Cutler Bay 33189
$664,900—32.51,953$34073East Coast Realty of Florida
19225 Franjo Rd
Cutler Bay 33157
$660,000$598K to $702K321,104$598130Legacy Realty Partners, LLC.
22651 SW 93rd Psge
Cutler Bay 33190
$660,000—532,869$23074Davide Realty Inc
19780 SW 101st Ave
Cutler Bay 33157
$659,000$597K to $701K421,644$40168La Costa Homes Realty
10265 Montego Bay Dr
Cutler Bay 33189
$659,000—431,556$4243Village Realty of S. Florida
20510 Jacaranda Rd
Cutler Bay 33189
$650,000$576K to $704K321,264$51489EXP Realty, LLC
19202 SW 99th Ave
Cutler Bay 33157
$650,000$538K to $743K331,582$41117Keller Williams Realty Premier Properties
(786) 205-1454
20210 SW 106th Ct
Cutler Bay 33189
$650,000—421,534$42410Oakleaf Realty, LLC.
20700 Leeward Ln
Cutler Bay 33189
$649,900$589K to $691K421,584$41089Results Realty of Dade County
18670 Belview Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$649,000$588K to $690K421,972$329151Lifestyle International Realty
8932 Ridgeland Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$649,000$588K to $690K321,320$49244Serhant
20111 SW 84th Ave
Cutler Bay 33189
$649,000$537K to $742K321,726$3766Luxe Properties
8856 SW 221st Ter
Cutler Bay 33190
$639,000—532,476$2581Luxe Properties
18581 SW 94th Ave
Cutler Bay 33157
$635,000$525K to $726K321,408$45118Miami Portfolio Collection
20601 Dothan Rd
Cutler Bay 33189
$635,000—321,878$33812Lifestyle International Realty
8943 SW 206th St
Cutler Bay 33189
$630,000$571K to $670K42.52,126$29632NuFront International Realty
9852 SW 196th St
Cutler Bay 33157
$629,900—421,992$31622Best American Realty Corp
9365 Jamaica Dr
Cutler Bay 33189
$629,000$570K to $669K321,928$326252Cutler Realty, Inc.
9031 SW 208th Ter
Cutler Bay 33189
$629,000—32.52,128$296215RE/MAX Advance Realty II
(786) 395-1944
21448 SW 89th Path
Cutler Bay 33189
$625,000—321,437$4359HomeCoast Realty, LLC
21514 SW 90th Ave
Cutler Bay 33189
$624,900$566K to $665K42.51,880$33230Coldwell Banker Realty
22759 SW 93rd Ct
Cutler Bay 33190
$619,000—52.52,492$24840Keller Williams Realty SW
19430 Lenaire Dr
Cutler Bay 33157
$618,000—421,957$31617Coldwell Banker Realty
8836 SW 221 TERR
Miami 33190
$610,000—42——152Lifestyle International Realty

Insider Price is the range a house is likely to sell in, worked out from its asking price and what houses in Cutler Bay actually closed at, or in a wider area where Cutler Bay has had too few sales. It is not shown on Ricky Garcia's own listings, or where the seller asked that automated estimates not appear with the listing. How it works and how accurate it has been.

Sorting a column reorders the 60 houses on this page only. The pages run from the highest asking price down.

Ricky Garcia

Buying in Cutler Bay?

Get the numbers before you write an offer

What comparable houses actually closed for, how long they took to sell, what the lot and the flood zone mean for insurance, and what to check before an offer. Ricky Garcia walks you through all of it, free, with no pressure to buy.

Ask Ricky about Cutler Bay → Call (305) 33-RICKY

Selling in Cutler Bay?

What Cutler Bay houses actually sell for

These numbers come from closed MLS sales in Cutler Bay, not asking prices. The pattern is the same in every neighborhood: houses priced to the market go under contract in weeks; overpriced houses sit, get cut, and close lower. Ricky Garcia prepares a free market analysis for your house: what comparable houses actually closed for, what is competing with you right now, and a list price that gets showings in the first two weeks. No obligation.

723sales closed, last 24 months
96%of the original asking price (median sale)
47%of sellers cut their price before selling
44 daysto sell (median)
$355per sq ft, recent sales

Get my free market analysis → Call (305) 33-RICKY

Nearby neighborhoods

What's my Cutler Bay home worth?

723 houses sold in Cutler Bay in the last 24 months, at a median of $629K. Is yours above or below that? Give Ricky the address and he'll email you a price range built from those sales, with the sales listed. You don't have to list with him.

Escríbale en español si prefiere.

Add a note

Your message goes to Ricky's own inbox and is used only to answer you, never sold. Asking costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Or call (305) 337-4259.

How we decide what's in Cutler Bay: each house is placed by its county property record, which says which city it is in, not by what the listing calls itself.